The survey focused on the question of how distribution system operators mastered the integration of renewable energy systems and financed the investments required to expand electricity grids. The researchers interviewed company directors and grid planners from ten leading distribution system operators in Germany. Between them, the companies account for 38 percent of the distribution grid in Germany in terms of circuit length.
Grid integration a success, but smart grid technologies struggling to gain ground
The survey showed that, following the introduction of incentive regulation, distribution system operators first sought to optimize the existing grids before turning to conventional grid expansion measures. Overall, they were reluctant to invest in smart technologies such as voltage-regulated local distribution transformers, which, unlike conventional transformers, can adjust the voltage ratio without interrupting the power supply and thus facilitate the feed-in of wind and solar power. This capability makes them an economic option for connecting medium-voltage and local grids. The interviewees expressed a desire for greater support for the introduction of smart technologies, but emphasized that these are no substitute for grid expansion measures. Some interviewees suggested that the potential of smart technologies was overrated by political actors.
Challenges are of a political rather than technical nature
Most of the respondents identified the financing of grid integration measures as a greater challenge than the technical issues arising in the course of expansion and modernisation measures. The interviews revealed a distribution conflict between grid operators and grid users. Grid operators, for example, benefit from a higher rate of interest on equity capital. However, these costs are then passed on to consumers, who wish to see lower electricity costs. Resolving this conflict while taking local conditions into account is one of the greatest challenges facing regulators.
While a number of critical issues were raised by respondents, the authors conclude that efforts to integrate decentralised power generation plants in Germany have been successful. With its comprehensive description of the legal context, the article closes an important gap in the research landscape, explains co-author Adela Marian: “An easily-understandable explanation of the German approach to incentive regulation has not been available in English until now. This article is a timely contribution, especially in light of the large-scale expansion of renewable energy and Germany’s role as an international frontrunner in this field.” Incentive regulation offers a model for other countries to follow, the article suggests, however the financing solutions would have to be adapted to local conditions.
Matschoss, P., Bayer, B., Thomas, H., Marian, A. (2019). The German incentive regulation and its practical impact on the grid integration of renewable energy systems. - Renewable energy: an international journal, 134, p. 727-738. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2018.10.103
Contents and key insights:
- The regulation principles for German distribution grid operators are presented.
- The elements determining the revenue cap for grid operators are explained in detail.
- Representatives from leading German grid operators shared their experiences in interviews.
- The German regulatory framework enables operators to recover costs relating to the integration of renewables.
- The creation of appropriate incentives for smart technologies remains a challenge.